Researchers from Brazil and the United States report on results from their study suggesting that direct observation cannot be considered to be the "gold standard" for assessing hand hygiene compliance. Marra, et al. (2010) compared three measures of hand hygiene adherence -- direct observation of practice, product usage (alcohol-based handrub and chlorhexidine), and collection of data from electronic counting devices on dispensers -- in an intensive care unit during a 12-week observational study at a tertiary-care hospital. Their researcher was published in the August issue of Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology.
The researchers report that there were 2,249 opportunities for hand hygiene observed, and the overall rate of hand hygiene adherence was 62.3 percent (representing 1,402 cleansing episodes). A total of 76,389 dispensing episodes were recorded by the electronic devices. The average number of dispensing episodes per patient-day was 53.8. There was 64.1 mL of alcohol-based handrub used per patient-day (representing 65.5 percent of total product used) and 33.8 mL of chlorhexidine used per patient-day (representing 34.5 percent). The researchers say that there was no significant correlation between observed hand hygiene adherence and total product used per patient-day.
Marra, et al. (2010) conclude that "direct observation cannot be considered the gold standard for assessing hand hygiene, because there was no relationship between the observed adherence and the number of dispensing episodes or the volume of product used. Other means to monitor hand hygiene adherence, such as electronic devices and measurement of product usage, should be considered."
Reference: Marra AR, Moura DF, Paes AT, Pavão dos Santos OF, Edmond MB. Measuring Rates of Hand Hygiene Adherence in the Intensive Care Setting: A Comparative Study of Direct Observation, Product Usage, and Electronic Counting Devices. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2010;31:796-801.
Stay prepared and protected with Infection Control Today's newsletter, delivering essential updates, best practices, and expert insights for infection preventionists.
The Next Frontier in Infection Control: AI-Driven Operating Rooms
Published: July 15th 2025 | Updated: July 15th 2025Discover how AI-powered sensors, smart surveillance, and advanced analytics are revolutionizing infection prevention in the OR. Herman DeBoard, PhD, discusses how these technologies safeguard sterile fields, reduce SSIs, and help hospitals balance operational efficiency with patient safety.
A Helping Hand: Innovative Approaches to Expanding Hand Hygiene Programs in Acute Care Settings
July 9th 2025Who knew candy, UV lights, and a college kid in scrubs could double hand hygiene adherence? A Pennsylvania hospital’s creative shake-up of its infection prevention program shows that sometimes it takes more than soap to get hands clean—and keep them that way.