Electronic Monitoring Using 5-Moments Method Provides Accurate, Actionable HH Compliance Data
Two primary hand hygiene (HH) methods exist. The In/Out method teaches staff to clean their hands at entry to and exit from patient rooms. This method is easy to measure, but suffers from the potential for recontamination of staff from fomites after room entry. The World Health Organization (WHO) 5-Moments method teaches additional HH opportunities (HHOs) after entry to the patient room. It is difficult to measure and requires known direct observation. Diller et al. (2013) describe the development and validation of a 5-Moments electronic monitoring system. The system captures soap/sanitizer dispenser activations with an implanted RF circuit board in the dispensers and transmits data via a wireless network to offsite servers. The activations represent the numerator. We previously developed an algorithm driven by patient census and nurse/patient staffing ratios to predict the number of HHOs (denominator) expected on medical/surgical, ICU or ED units (HOW2 Benchmark Study: AJIC 2011;39). The HH compliance index (HHCI) equals the activations divided by the predicted HHOs during a time period. The HOW2 algorithm was derived from direct observation of periods of care activity, so we performed a validation study using 24 hour video-taped surveillance. The researchers reviewed 1,511 hours of video for 26 patients on a medical unit over 15 months and compared the actual HH compliance rate from the video-tape to the predicted HHCI from the system. Quarterly HH compliance rates by direct observation ranged from 92 to 99%. The electronic HHCI ranged from 65 to 71%, while actual HH compliance from video-surveillance ranged from 66 to 75%. Correlation of the latter two metrics was extremely high (r = 0.976, p=0.004). The number of HHOs with the In/Out method (2886) was 36% lower than with the 5-Moments method (4522). This study validates the HOW2 Benchmark Study algorithm. It also documents a 36% deficit in HHOs using the In/Out method and a ~30% Hawthorne Effect due to direct observation. There is an extremely high correlation between actual video-taped HH compliance and the electronic monitoring systems HHCI. The researchers say they believe that electronic monitoring using the 5-Moments method provides the most accurate and actionable HH compliance data. Reference: T Diller, JW Kelly, C Steed, D Blackhurst, S Boeker and P Alper. Oral presentation O016 at the 2nd International Conference on Prevention and Infection Control (ICPIC 2013): Electronic hand hygiene monitoring for the WHO 5-moments method. Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control 2013, 2(Suppl 1):O16 doi:10.1186/2047-2994-2-S1-O16 Disclosures: T. Diller Grant/Research support from Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc., J. Kelly Grant/Research support from Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc., C. Steed Grant/Research support from Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc., D. Blackhurst Grant/Research support from Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc., S. Boeker Grant/Research support from Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc., P. Alper Employee of Deb Worldwide Healthcare, Inc.
Tackling Health Care-Associated Infections: SHEA’s Bold 10-Year Research Plan to Save Lives
December 12th 2024Discover SHEA's visionary 10-year plan to reduce HAIs by advancing infection prevention strategies, understanding transmission, and improving diagnostic practices for better patient outcomes.
Point-of-Care Engagement in Long-Term Care Decreasing Infections
November 26th 2024Get Well’s digital patient engagement platform decreases hospital-acquired infection rates by 31%, improves patient education, and fosters involvement in personalized care plans through real-time interaction tools.
The Leapfrog Group and the Positive Effect on Hospital Hand Hygiene
November 21st 2024The Leapfrog Group enhances hospital safety by publicizing hand hygiene performance, improving patient safety outcomes, and significantly reducing health care-associated infections through transparent standards and monitoring initiatives.
The Importance of Hand Hygiene in Clostridioides difficile Reduction
November 18th 2024Clostridioides difficile infections burden US healthcare. Electronic Hand Hygiene Monitoring (EHHMS) systems remind for soap and water. This study evaluates EHHMS effectiveness by comparing C difficile cases in 10 hospitals with CMS data, linking EHHMS use to reduced cases.
